KABC-TV Los Angeles: Gov Candidates Brown, Whitman meet to debate
That's right, folks--after 2 long months of relocating, working, studying, and various other forms of college student diversion, I am BACK with a brand new election-season rant! Tonight marked the opening episode of the California gubernatorial debates, and for many politically-minded Californians, the moment we've all been waiting for. Held at UC Davis, this debate was the perfect opportunity for Meg Whitman and Jerry Brown to publicly explain their plans for the governorship, as well as address some of the issues that have been so gossiped about in the press the last few months. While I strongly encourage every Californian to watch this debate for themselves, I simply can't resist the urge to recap it.
First off, I was completely and utterly surprised at Whitman's debating style. She presented herself much better than I (or anyone else for that matter) expected, although it wasn't perfect; I did find her incessant repetition of talking-points-in-a-can quite annoying, and also caught a few weak spots in her arguments, not to mention that she used the word "child" twice in referring to California public university students. Brown brought up a few good points and performed like the seasoned politician that he is, but in my opinion, made some far-fetched claims and dropped the ball on some sensitive topics.
The issue of California's ever-tardy, ever-gluttonous state budget was the first point of discussion. Finally the candidates were able to talk about something in a formal setting, free of mudslinging (or in Meg's case, cash-slinging) advertisements or op-eds. I gave Brown the first point of the evening for his budget plan, which involves cutting his own budget 15% as well as challenging our state legislature to do the same, while making the budgeting process more transparent and taking the backroom politics out of the equation for good. Whitman's plan involves...a two-year budget cycle, rather than the fiscal year that the Fed and the entire rest of the economy is currently running on?...seems to me that more budget confusion isn't exactly what we need. I gave neither candidate points when it came to their job creation strategies. Whitman's proposal to eliminate the startup tax was well-played, but her biggest plan involves eliminating the factory tax and crossing our fingers for manufacturing to pick back up where it left off, and Brown's dream is an all-out hippie offensive from the already grossly over-subsidized green sector. Thanks for the suggestions guys, but as one of the millions of students getting ready to graduate from a four-year university with student loan debt, I'm really not inclined to settle for a job in assembly line production or retrofitting solar panels to roofs in the scorching California sun.
Speaking of education, I reluctantly had to throw Meg Whitman her first point of the night when the question of UC/CSU/CC fee increases came up. I was so disappointed by Jerry Brown's argument--he started out by saying how much he loved the UC system...but when the panelist asked him if he pledged to hold the line on student fees from now on, he backpedaled and refused to stand his ground on the issue. Come on, Jerry! Even Arnold was able to rein in the chaos a little for the '10-'11 school year! Whitman, on the other hand, actually proposed strategically streamlining and siphoning money from other areas of the government (namely welfare programs and staffing) in order to keep our universities going, although I found it slightly ironic that she kept bringing up downsizing on government staff, which would require cutting hundreds, even thousands, of jobs, when she made job creation one of her key issues. Looks like she's learning the ropes of politics pretty fast if you know what I mean.
Immigration was where the debate really got interesting. Nobody can deny the problems we face as a border state, and I must award this point to Jerry Brown, although more on the basis of my own personal bias. Brown's strategy was both rational and feasible: implement efficient law enforcement programs that deport and take action against the undocumented immigrants that are actually committing crimes, then work on a peaceful path to legal citizenship for Mexican immigrants. Whitman expressed her opinion that the Arizona immigration law was too "divisive", then immediately flipped the script and talked about taking action against every illegal immigrant in the state. She can think what she may, but if she seriously thinks that she's ever going to be able to afford or enforce such a plan and hunt down and deport literally tens of thousands of off-the-books immigrants, then she knows even less about policy implications than I thought.
The night's festivities ended with a humorous discussion of fresh political-press gossip. Meg's campaign strategies, namely her flat-out lying TV commercials and her $90 million personal check, were addressed, and while she went on the mother of all tangents when confronted about some of her ads, she made a pretty good point about the funding: by paying for much of the campaign herself, she holds herself accountable to no one else. A good point, but I still can't help but think someone made up all this stuff for her and made a pretty penny. Brown, a long-time slave of labor unions and other liberal pity-parties, testified that he is now much too old to care about special interest liabilities and other traditional games of public office. He then ruined his progress by running over time with a corny shout-out to vote no on Prop 23, which by the way, Whitman supports, and unfortunately I have to give her another point for being on my side of the enviro-policy battle.
No matter which way you cut it, this debate was the most interesting thing that has happened since the start of this campaign. About 30 days and a few more debates remain...who's it gonna be? The sketchy 1970's "moonbeam" governor from the Bay Area? Or the sketchy corporate bigwig rookie from the Bay Area?
...Personally I think we're screwed either way, but there's no point in politics if you don't at least try to participate! In the words of Stan Marsh, "I learned that I better get used to having to pick between a Douche and a Turd Sandwich, because that's usually the choice I'll have" (South Park Studios). Couldn't have said it any better myself.
Showing posts with label meg whitman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meg whitman. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 28, 2010
Friday, July 9, 2010
The impending demise of the Golden State and politics in general
Sorry I haven't updated in awhile, it's campaign season and everything has been crazy, both personally for me as well as in recent news. Nothing of any substance is happening, just more of the usual mudslinging, fear mongering, and horrific journalism that made our country what it is today.
I simply can't believe what I'm seeing in this general election campaign--I guess I knew it was coming all along but it just happened so fast. The average Californian voters (and Americans in general, I think) have finally proven without a doubt that they are no longer capable of making informed decisions. I know this because the percentage points in favor of every campaign have been swinging from week to week with no actual event to drive the fluctuation besides new ad campaigns. These people are not only relying on television for entertainment anymore, no--they now rely on it for all their information and personal decision-making processes. Apparently people these days have no problem succumbing to a life of sitting on the couch and letting the press and corporate America soak their mind in "opinions" (FYI: it's not your "opinion" if you heard it on TV, that's someone else's opinion). I don't watch TV (except ESPN, mind you), and I think that's what has helped me form such an objective perspective on law and politics. When debating or discussing politics with others, I can tell just by the word choice and arguing style of a person whether or not they are speaking for themselves or quoting a commercial back to me. It's very difficult to reason with these people because they usually feel compelled to stand firm on issues favored specifically by their political party--issues made known, of course, through partisan news networks and commercials. The biggest problem with this mentality is that our politicians are not making it any better...corrupt governments + braindead voters = chaos on the horizon.
First example, the governor race in California. To the educated, TV-less, moderate-minded observer, Meg Whitman is obviously an idiot. She still hasn't revealed any political skill to the voters, but she has already run the most expensive gubernatorial campaign of all time, and we're still 4 months away from the election. Too bad she has completely flip-flopped on a major issue that Republicans seem to feel very strongly about: immigration. In June, she tried to buddy up with Pete Wilson, a strong supporter of the controversial Arizona law. She promised the Reps that she'd be "tough on immigration" and even included photos of the border fence and statements about her distaste for the notion of amnesty for illegals in her 30-second TV commercials. This caused many Latino voters to shy away from her. Now, she has broken off contact with Wilson and launched a SPANISH ad campaign, complete with billboards saying "NO a la Proposicion 187 y NO a la ley de Arizona." Since the start of this particular project she has gained significant support from Latinos and is even catching up to Jerry Brown in that respect. Race issues aside (because I literally do not care what race a person is--it's what's going on inside the mind, and everyone is guilty in this case), these people believed a billboard and a few commercials rather than all the things Whitman said publicly back in June. Furthermore, even her Mexico-hating Republican supporters haven't noticed the flip-flop! The commercials they're getting on mainstream TV are making them happy enough I guess. But it just goes to show how people are making decisions these days, and it's quite scary. As far as Brown's campaign goes, I'm convinced he's going to lose simply because he hasn't represented himself solely in 30-second snippets. Which is fine by me, because I will not be voting for him either. I probably won't even vote for governor at all, as there are no qualified options. I'm almost clinging to Arnold for dear life.
The second problem I'm seeing is the press's selective distortion of facts regarding Prop 19, the marijuana initiative. As soon as the opposition came out with their lame attempt at a campaign, newspapers jumped all over it and are now publishing daily articles regarding the "dangers" of legalization, sometimes even 2 articles a day. Today they're reporting a miniscule drop in the polls that we already knew was going to happen (now 48% against, 44% for), but of course they are acting like legalization is done and the initiative will never pass now. Are you kidding me?! How do these people find any honor in that kind of speculation? As the opposition came out several months after the proponents, it's expected that their initial campaigning would slightly impact our poll results. It's common sense. It does not mean we can't bring that number back up in the next 4 months. This wouldn't be so upsetting if I didn't know that most people are going to believe everything they read and never listen to a single fact again. It's almost like the newspapers are being blackmailed by law enforcement to say these things and turn people against the initiative...I seriously wouldn't doubt it. On top of this, everyone seems to be literally ignoring the facts about marijuana. They say there are too many health risks involved (although they can't name a single health risk) and are afraid that stoned driving fatalities will come down upon us like a plague of locusts (even though millions have used the herb since cars were invented and we have never had widespread problems). I guess none of it matters because logic is dead for most Californians.
The biggest indicator of the downfall of our government system for me is the Oakland verdict yesterday regarding the BART station shooting of 22 year old Oscar Grant, an unarmed black man, by Johannes Mehserle, a white police officer. When Mehserle's "involuntary manslaughter" sentence was read yesterday at 4 PM, Oakland's worst fears were realized as protestors looted, rioted, and essentially wreaked havoc across the town. I hope no one will chide me for siding with these rioters, as I am a young and fairly revolutionary-minded individual who believes that if that many people are angry, it's something to take seriously. While many are calling the rioters out for being "unnecessarily destructive", I would suggest a bit of rhetoric on the Social Contract Theory.
We, the people, hand over some of our civil liberties in order to be protected and provided for by our government. The point here is that our governments, including their law enforcement agencies, have not held up their end of the bargain. We have paid income taxes and sales taxes into the system and helped develop California, and what have they done for us? Bankrupted their treasured "social programs" and plunged us into billions of dollars of debt that we will never be able to repay, and STILL begged us for more, while trying to control our actions in the name of "morality" and "tradition". They have prohibited, regulated, and taxed everything from businesses to bike helmets to our home appliances to the very food that we eat, and people are fed up. When a police officer can kill you simply for acting silly in the BART station and essentially get away with it in a court of law, people are going to get pissed off. And they are. And it's going to get worse. What happens when voters are literally too dumbed down to salvage what's left of the system? Maybe democracy is dying. Hopefully what comes after it is better.
If I didn't have such a compelling interest in saving this country from itself, I would give up on the whole thing. No rest for the weary...
I simply can't believe what I'm seeing in this general election campaign--I guess I knew it was coming all along but it just happened so fast. The average Californian voters (and Americans in general, I think) have finally proven without a doubt that they are no longer capable of making informed decisions. I know this because the percentage points in favor of every campaign have been swinging from week to week with no actual event to drive the fluctuation besides new ad campaigns. These people are not only relying on television for entertainment anymore, no--they now rely on it for all their information and personal decision-making processes. Apparently people these days have no problem succumbing to a life of sitting on the couch and letting the press and corporate America soak their mind in "opinions" (FYI: it's not your "opinion" if you heard it on TV, that's someone else's opinion). I don't watch TV (except ESPN, mind you), and I think that's what has helped me form such an objective perspective on law and politics. When debating or discussing politics with others, I can tell just by the word choice and arguing style of a person whether or not they are speaking for themselves or quoting a commercial back to me. It's very difficult to reason with these people because they usually feel compelled to stand firm on issues favored specifically by their political party--issues made known, of course, through partisan news networks and commercials. The biggest problem with this mentality is that our politicians are not making it any better...corrupt governments + braindead voters = chaos on the horizon.
First example, the governor race in California. To the educated, TV-less, moderate-minded observer, Meg Whitman is obviously an idiot. She still hasn't revealed any political skill to the voters, but she has already run the most expensive gubernatorial campaign of all time, and we're still 4 months away from the election. Too bad she has completely flip-flopped on a major issue that Republicans seem to feel very strongly about: immigration. In June, she tried to buddy up with Pete Wilson, a strong supporter of the controversial Arizona law. She promised the Reps that she'd be "tough on immigration" and even included photos of the border fence and statements about her distaste for the notion of amnesty for illegals in her 30-second TV commercials. This caused many Latino voters to shy away from her. Now, she has broken off contact with Wilson and launched a SPANISH ad campaign, complete with billboards saying "NO a la Proposicion 187 y NO a la ley de Arizona." Since the start of this particular project she has gained significant support from Latinos and is even catching up to Jerry Brown in that respect. Race issues aside (because I literally do not care what race a person is--it's what's going on inside the mind, and everyone is guilty in this case), these people believed a billboard and a few commercials rather than all the things Whitman said publicly back in June. Furthermore, even her Mexico-hating Republican supporters haven't noticed the flip-flop! The commercials they're getting on mainstream TV are making them happy enough I guess. But it just goes to show how people are making decisions these days, and it's quite scary. As far as Brown's campaign goes, I'm convinced he's going to lose simply because he hasn't represented himself solely in 30-second snippets. Which is fine by me, because I will not be voting for him either. I probably won't even vote for governor at all, as there are no qualified options. I'm almost clinging to Arnold for dear life.
The second problem I'm seeing is the press's selective distortion of facts regarding Prop 19, the marijuana initiative. As soon as the opposition came out with their lame attempt at a campaign, newspapers jumped all over it and are now publishing daily articles regarding the "dangers" of legalization, sometimes even 2 articles a day. Today they're reporting a miniscule drop in the polls that we already knew was going to happen (now 48% against, 44% for), but of course they are acting like legalization is done and the initiative will never pass now. Are you kidding me?! How do these people find any honor in that kind of speculation? As the opposition came out several months after the proponents, it's expected that their initial campaigning would slightly impact our poll results. It's common sense. It does not mean we can't bring that number back up in the next 4 months. This wouldn't be so upsetting if I didn't know that most people are going to believe everything they read and never listen to a single fact again. It's almost like the newspapers are being blackmailed by law enforcement to say these things and turn people against the initiative...I seriously wouldn't doubt it. On top of this, everyone seems to be literally ignoring the facts about marijuana. They say there are too many health risks involved (although they can't name a single health risk) and are afraid that stoned driving fatalities will come down upon us like a plague of locusts (even though millions have used the herb since cars were invented and we have never had widespread problems). I guess none of it matters because logic is dead for most Californians.
The biggest indicator of the downfall of our government system for me is the Oakland verdict yesterday regarding the BART station shooting of 22 year old Oscar Grant, an unarmed black man, by Johannes Mehserle, a white police officer. When Mehserle's "involuntary manslaughter" sentence was read yesterday at 4 PM, Oakland's worst fears were realized as protestors looted, rioted, and essentially wreaked havoc across the town. I hope no one will chide me for siding with these rioters, as I am a young and fairly revolutionary-minded individual who believes that if that many people are angry, it's something to take seriously. While many are calling the rioters out for being "unnecessarily destructive", I would suggest a bit of rhetoric on the Social Contract Theory.
We, the people, hand over some of our civil liberties in order to be protected and provided for by our government. The point here is that our governments, including their law enforcement agencies, have not held up their end of the bargain. We have paid income taxes and sales taxes into the system and helped develop California, and what have they done for us? Bankrupted their treasured "social programs" and plunged us into billions of dollars of debt that we will never be able to repay, and STILL begged us for more, while trying to control our actions in the name of "morality" and "tradition". They have prohibited, regulated, and taxed everything from businesses to bike helmets to our home appliances to the very food that we eat, and people are fed up. When a police officer can kill you simply for acting silly in the BART station and essentially get away with it in a court of law, people are going to get pissed off. And they are. And it's going to get worse. What happens when voters are literally too dumbed down to salvage what's left of the system? Maybe democracy is dying. Hopefully what comes after it is better.
If I didn't have such a compelling interest in saving this country from itself, I would give up on the whole thing. No rest for the weary...
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Why I don't trust women in politics--at least, not yet
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/dcnow/2010/06/steinem-criticizes-palin-for-using-feminist-brand.html
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/28/AR2010052802263.html?sid=ST2010062204464
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/06/20/MNC51E1A95.DTL&type=politics&tsp=1
And the list of stories goes on and on. The media just can't control themselves these days when it comes to women in politics, especially in California, where the big names on the November ballot are 3/4 women. Other areas are catching on as well: Nikki Haley has snatched the Republican party gubernatorial bid in South Carolina, Michele Bachmann continues to gain popularity in Minnesota, and the infamous Sarah Palin is surrounded by rumors of a 2012 presidential race. What do all these women have in common? Thanks to Sarah Palin, they are all now being labeled as "feminists" by the mass media and spurring a new "conservative feminist" movement among American women. It may sound like a good idea, but I do not see these women as even remotely inspiring and do not believe that they have what it takes to make it in the political system in the long term.
This new movement of "conservative feminists" has been criticized by their original, more liberal counterparts, for opposing traditional feminist values. While abortion rights and sexual freedom for women was a huge topic of feminism in the 70s, this new wave of politicians is strictly pro-life as well as rigid in their opposition to gay marriage. Starting to sound like a trend? That's because it is. Conservatives are struggling to make their voices heard and pushing an old-fashioned religious agenda to do it. The Republican party and "Tea Party" which these women represent are already losing public approval because of the myriad religion-based social views they promote. Critics of the "conservative feminists" have come out in the media saying that these women should not be labeling themselves as women's rights activists when they obviously oppose a woman's right to make decisions regarding family planning, reproductive health, and sexuality.
I agree with the critics--it was pure idiocy on Sarah Palin's part to attempt to associate herself with a group of people that despises her views, but what more could we expect from her anyway? While several women feel empowered by the pep-rally-esque "conservative feminism" movement, I'm definitely not buying it, and I hope you aren't either. These women have no political talent or experience, just heaps of money from business ventures, family, et cetera. They come with baggage for miles (Meg Whitman's Goldman Sachs controversy/eBay employee shoving/parenting issues, Nikki Haley's alleged sex scandals, Sarah Palin's resignation as Governor/family issues). They usually refuse to speak in public, but if they do, they never have anything to say besides canned campaign speeches and cute phrases. And worst of all, they base their political ideology on the specific religious beliefs of Christianity and look down on women who believe in true civil rights for all people. Also, don't think I'm only against conservative she-politicians, the liberal ones can be just as bad (ie Hillary, Barbara Boxer), but at least they're not clogging up news sites making fools of themselves every other day.
Don't get me wrong--I'm very proud of how far women have come in the US. We now make up a vast percentage of business executives, attorneys, and other high-power careers. We have the freedom to an education, a vote, and a choice to abort. And yes, we can run for public office. We can basically do whatever we want! But the "conservative feminist" movement is an example of over-reaching. These women are incapable of handling themselves with dignity in public or in the press, and can barely muster up the words to describe their views on any other policies besides anti-abortion and anti-gay. In my opinion, they are an embarrassment to smart, politics-savvy women who just aren't in a position to be elected. Feminism is a trend, just a hat that these female politicians have decided to put on just to get easy media airtime. Just because women can run for office doesn't mean all of them should. The same goes for male candidates! And personally, I won't vote for any woman in politics until one stands out as the best that our gender has to offer. I assure you it won't happen in 2010.
Share
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/28/AR2010052802263.html?sid=ST2010062204464
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/06/20/MNC51E1A95.DTL&type=politics&tsp=1
And the list of stories goes on and on. The media just can't control themselves these days when it comes to women in politics, especially in California, where the big names on the November ballot are 3/4 women. Other areas are catching on as well: Nikki Haley has snatched the Republican party gubernatorial bid in South Carolina, Michele Bachmann continues to gain popularity in Minnesota, and the infamous Sarah Palin is surrounded by rumors of a 2012 presidential race. What do all these women have in common? Thanks to Sarah Palin, they are all now being labeled as "feminists" by the mass media and spurring a new "conservative feminist" movement among American women. It may sound like a good idea, but I do not see these women as even remotely inspiring and do not believe that they have what it takes to make it in the political system in the long term.
This new movement of "conservative feminists" has been criticized by their original, more liberal counterparts, for opposing traditional feminist values. While abortion rights and sexual freedom for women was a huge topic of feminism in the 70s, this new wave of politicians is strictly pro-life as well as rigid in their opposition to gay marriage. Starting to sound like a trend? That's because it is. Conservatives are struggling to make their voices heard and pushing an old-fashioned religious agenda to do it. The Republican party and "Tea Party" which these women represent are already losing public approval because of the myriad religion-based social views they promote. Critics of the "conservative feminists" have come out in the media saying that these women should not be labeling themselves as women's rights activists when they obviously oppose a woman's right to make decisions regarding family planning, reproductive health, and sexuality.
I agree with the critics--it was pure idiocy on Sarah Palin's part to attempt to associate herself with a group of people that despises her views, but what more could we expect from her anyway? While several women feel empowered by the pep-rally-esque "conservative feminism" movement, I'm definitely not buying it, and I hope you aren't either. These women have no political talent or experience, just heaps of money from business ventures, family, et cetera. They come with baggage for miles (Meg Whitman's Goldman Sachs controversy/eBay employee shoving/parenting issues, Nikki Haley's alleged sex scandals, Sarah Palin's resignation as Governor/family issues). They usually refuse to speak in public, but if they do, they never have anything to say besides canned campaign speeches and cute phrases. And worst of all, they base their political ideology on the specific religious beliefs of Christianity and look down on women who believe in true civil rights for all people. Also, don't think I'm only against conservative she-politicians, the liberal ones can be just as bad (ie Hillary, Barbara Boxer), but at least they're not clogging up news sites making fools of themselves every other day.
Don't get me wrong--I'm very proud of how far women have come in the US. We now make up a vast percentage of business executives, attorneys, and other high-power careers. We have the freedom to an education, a vote, and a choice to abort. And yes, we can run for public office. We can basically do whatever we want! But the "conservative feminist" movement is an example of over-reaching. These women are incapable of handling themselves with dignity in public or in the press, and can barely muster up the words to describe their views on any other policies besides anti-abortion and anti-gay. In my opinion, they are an embarrassment to smart, politics-savvy women who just aren't in a position to be elected. Feminism is a trend, just a hat that these female politicians have decided to put on just to get easy media airtime. Just because women can run for office doesn't mean all of them should. The same goes for male candidates! And personally, I won't vote for any woman in politics until one stands out as the best that our gender has to offer. I assure you it won't happen in 2010.
Share
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)